The Evidence Is Growing
Researchers from HHL Leipzig Graduate School of Management (PDF, opens in a new window) ran a controlled experiment on exactly this question. They submitted more than 2,500 standardized prompts to ChatGPT about 20 publicly listed companies, covering financial performance, executive compensation, strategy, risk, and sustainability disclosure.
The sample had been structured as a matched pair. Ten companies had published a full HTML annual report. Ten had published as a PDF. Same kinds of companies, same kinds of questions, different format.
Three findings stand out.
- Corporate reporting were at the center of answer. Of the 24,662 citations analyzed, 59% pointed directly at the company's own polished annual report. Add the IR website and the corporate site and roughly 85% of citations were to company-owned content. The LLM wants to use the company owned materials. That is genuinely good news, and it undercuts the assumption that LLMs are off somewhere ignoring primary disclosure.
- Format decides whether it can be cited or not. Companies with HTML reports were cited three times more often for annual report content than their PDF-publishing peers.
- This is the finding with real consequences: when the LLM couldn’t cite the company's own document, it went somewhere else. Answers about companies reporting by PDF contained roughly 2.7 times more third-party citations. The substitutes were largely financial data aggregators: MarketScreener, Bloomberg, Reuters. External summaries of your numbers, with a narrative you did not write, are being used in place of your own numbers. Accuracy also moved with it. In the sample researchers checked for factual correctness.